See MENU & Order Online
Open for Pickup and Delivery!

Home of the Giant Slice
sandwich pizza

About us

Pizza Heaven of New Windsor, NY is celebrating 25 years in business serving great pizza, pasta, and more, made from only the best, quality ingredients. Pizza Heaven is home to the giant slice and we offer a full restaurant menu of delicious Italian specialties, all home-cooked by us. At Pizza Heaven of New Windsor we pride ourselves on our friendly, courteous and talented staff. It is our ultimate goal to please our customers and make them feel at home, like they are part of the family. We put our passion into every dish!

Trip Advisor
Mount Saint Mary's University

2010 - 1st place Mount Saint Mary's Pizza contest - Best in Newburgh

Times Herald Record

2008 - 1st Place Orange County Pizza Contest Times Herald Record


2006 - 2nd place 2006 Hudson Valley k104 call in for the best pizzeria

Our Menu

Pizza, dinners, wraps, salads, specialty pizza, wings, giant slices, canolis, cheesecake, gluten free, eat-in, take-out. We deliver lunch and dinner, lunch and dinner specials. Catering for any occasion

Where to find us

357 Old Forge Hill Rd #600, New Windsor, NY 12553

Our Hours